Jonathan J. Bonk. Orbis Books, 2007, 272 pp. Three of Five stars
Back in 2006 when I first arrived in South Africa, I lived in a much poorer setting than I do today. Was I better off back then?
Before offering an answer, I agree with Bonk that missionaries need to think more carefully about financial matters as it relates to their field of ministry. Many do live too extravagantly. Because missions and finances is a such a complicated matter, it deserves much reflection, dialogue, and counsel.
This leads to the purpose statement of Bonk’s book:
“The arguments in favor of Western missionary affluence are strong, sensible, and effective enough to persuade most missionaries that personal affluence, when appropriated with Christian moderation, is–on economic, domestic, social, and strategic grounds–infinitely preferable to the alternative. The next three chapters examine the case for the alternative.” (p.50)
Bonk’s greatest weakness is that he never analyses the reasons for poverty. It is enough for him to know that poverty exists. Now how must we deal with it.
If a society’s poverty is a result of sin, as opposed to government regulations or natural disasters, should this make any difference in the way a missionary lives. I think the answer is yes. Bonk doesn’t discuss it.
This book forces the reader to grapple with complications surrounding missions and money. On that basis, I would recommend the book.