— Evan Cantrell

The audio version of this article is available here: YouTube, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.
On 4 February 2026, a pregnant woman was gunned down in a home invasion. Her murder also caused the death of her unborn child, due to be delivered next month. If caught, however, her killer will be charged with only one murder. The reason for this goes back to the case of the State v David Best.
On Valentine’s Day 2006, Melissa Shelver and her boyfriend, David Best, were on their way home from her 38-week scan with the gynaecologist when, in an apparent hijacking, Best was shot in the shoulder, and Shelver was shot twice through the side of her stomach. Two teams of doctors performed emergency surgery on the mother and child, attempting to save the baby by an emergency caesarean section. Shelver survived, but the doctors were unable to save baby Jenna-May. Her spine had been shattered by the bullets fired into Shelver’s womb.
Best later confessed that he had plotted to stage the murder due to his relationship with another woman. He was arrested and charged with the murder of his unborn child. In his trial, the judge recognised that baby Jenna-May experienced her murder no differently than a child the same age outside of the womb would have.
Continue reading




























